blog




  • Essay / Comparative analysis of Montana 1948 and The Crucible

    Although set in different eras of American history, the revisionist novel Montana 1948 written by Larry Watson explores the corruption of the justice system and the nepotistic community of Bentrock. Similarly, the allegorical play "The Crucible" set in the 1950s, during the McCarthyism era, depicts a society in which submissive individuals are subjected to an overly controlling religious regime which ultimately leads to a disordered society. Miller also implies that crisis situations can reveal the true nature of an individual and insinuates preconceived notions that separate communities. The innate need to blame someone in order to accuse others of their wrongdoing can pave the way for a highly imperfect society and show how the manipulation of power can lead to the detriment of others. Both describe societies in which the sense of justice is distorted to preserve the importance of reputation. Furthermore, this illustrates that within their respective societies, their societies are dominated by the men who hold the most power to eradicate the superiority of women. The way the characters are portrayed shows how those in control of power manipulate the systems to suit their own interests ultimately differ. Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on “Why Violent Video Games Should Not Be Banned”? Get an original essay Both texts explore a period of crisis that threatens the reputation of those in power and choose to hide the truth to defend their reputation. In The Crucible, Miller describes the tendency of individuals to take advantage of their reputation to achieve their own interests, thus plaguing the community of Salem. This is manifested when John Proctor is faced with a dilemma: confessing his wrongdoings, which consequently results in a tainted reputation. Likewise, there is a moral dilemma in Montana that precipitates conflict within the Hayden family. In Montana in 1948, Wes faces a dilemma: uphold the law or stay loyal to his family. Gail states that "crimes are supposed to go unpunished", acting as a moral compass influencing her opinions. With Wes having the ultimate power as sheriff in Mercer County, it is his duty to uphold the law. His values ​​are torn between the reputation of the “Hayden” family and service to the community. It is obvious that Montana illustrates that reputation is everything whereas in the Crucible, people ignore their puritanical views and use their reputation in order to preserve their status. Both texts describe the lack of empowerment that women face in their oppressive societies, as actions are dictated by their own status. respective companies. By portraying Tituba as a slave with limited power and authority, Miller illustrates the injustice women faced despite their continued advocacy for freedom. Miller's direction insinuates that women's superiority does not exist, as evidenced by Tituba "falling on her knees" to ask for mercy and freedom. The Crucible highlights the lack of empowerment embedded in Salem society, which fuels witchcraft hysteria. In Likewise in Montana 1948, the nepotistic society of Bentrock is dominated by the Hayden family who hold the most power in the town. This is depicted by the characterization of Frank sexually abusing Native American women and murdering Marie. Commonly held perceptions of Native Americans are "lazy and superstitious", making it unlikely that Frank would be charged with the murder of Marie Little Soldier. This underlines the idea that Frank is a.